Family privacy, blogging about family

Author’s note: Edited after original posting, for clarity.

I wrote one draft. Deleted it. I wrote another. Deleted it. Another one. Deleted it. Another one…

You get it.

This was a difficult post to compose, the previous post, anyway. I wrote it, I believe, very well. But the content — although it may have been tasteful, and identities were left unnamed — was of a sensitive nature for a relative I hold dear. Nothing that I put down could erase that fact. And so, after speaking with this loved one and desiring to abide by their wishes, I decided not to publish my experience receiving my first batch of vital records last week (Wednesday); an experience that I had found to be bittersweet.

As a genealogy blogger, how do you balance both chronicling your family history research while still protecting the privacy of your loved ones, for the living and deceased?

Balancing that is real tough! If you go to my blog, you’ll see that when I wrote about my mom for the Carnival of Genealogy 48th Edition: http://allmybranches.wordpress.com/2008/05/14/on-the-spot-education/
I tried to keep as much as I could private. I also had to do the same thing with the CoG 51st Edition: http://allmybranches.wordpress.com/2008/06/28/independent-from-birth-carnival-of-genealogy-51st-edition/
because the person I wrote about still has living relatives and I didn’t want to offend anyone. Good luck!

Thanks Wendy for your response! It seems, although difficult, you were able to balance that line very well. Your mother sounds like an awesome woman! Perhaps I’ll revisit the topic, I set out to write on, at a later date, and try to approach it in a different manner.

This can be difficult, but there are a few simple rules to keep in mind. First, your family’s privacy should be uppermost in your mind when thinking about living relatives. You don’t have to publish everything you discover. Second, with living relatives, consider getting their permission about publishing anything you think is sensitive. If you have any hesitation about asking them, then probably you shouldn’t publish it. If the matter is so compelling that you must publish it, keep identities of living persons private. There can be legal liability for invasion of privacy (not that any of your relatives necessarily would actually sue you . . . but I’m just sayin’ . . . !). By the way, all of us who’ve been doing this for any time at all have had the experience of cringing after we’ve hit the “publish” button and wondering if we did the right thing or not.

Hey Craig. Thanks for your input! Yes. Absolutely. Our family’s privacy should be of the utmost importance. I sought my loved one’s permission because of that standard that I have set for myself, and what has been set in general within the world of genealogy. The main intent of this blog is to help my family, not hurt them. And I want to feel clean about all that I post here.

Welcome to the genea-blogosphere, Jeanna! I’ve added your blog to my Google Reader, and hope to read more from you, soon!

You may be interested in reading other African-American genealogy blogs, and Chris Dunham has a list here: http://blogfinder.genealogue.com/african-american.asp

Go here to add your blog to his list: http://blogfinder.genealogue.com/suggest_blog.asp

This is the topic of one of my very first posts at my genealogy/family history blog. I am lucky in that not many of my relatives have found my blog or they just don’t use what they call “The Internets” or “that Internet thing.”

When I cleaned out my mother’s house two years ago, I found letters and information that was and still is un-nerving for me. Much of it has raised many questions about me and how I interact with my family.

What I chose to do is this:

- I have one aunt with whom I am close and I get on the phone and chat with her about some of the issues.

- I’ve decided not to post on some of the “skeletons” as I call them.

- I have however, written something for the next person to take up my research and materials from me. This was part of my estate planning this past month. I was so worried that no one in my large family would want all the letters and photos, that I placed a directive to my executor to find a relative who was interested; and if no relative could be found, to contact several genealogy and/or historical societies that might have an interest.

So I have a “note” around a stack of letters that explains the way in which I’ve interpreted what was written - realizing that in 40 or 50 years the next person may have more information or even a different perspective.

And, being the good “archivist” I am, I have scanned all the letters and saved them on my computer.

Charles Hansen

Charles Hansen’s avatar

I would not post anything about any living person without their permission. The federal census is closed for 72 years because of privacy so we as genealogists should follow that or be more strict.

Charles

Hello Jeanna,

You’re in good company judging by the comments you received.
I don’t think I can really add any additional insights.

Like you, I’ve been trying to learn about my ancestors in order to understand things about myself. If you go to my blog, you’ll see that I blend photographs, stories, and documents of not only my ancestors but also of myself and some relatives. I’m careful not to divulge any privacy infringing stuff. (My new cousin Ron who lives in ___ was recently released from prison and can be reached at 555-123-4576 and here’s a picture…). I don’t do stuff like that or throw light on some current family dirt. LOL

However, I will keep private notes of things that may prove helpful with my ongoing research. Just my two ducats…

Peace,
“Guided by the Ancestors”

Thank you everyone for checking out my blog and offering advice!

@Miriam - Thanks for the add! Currently I’m listed in blogfinder under personal research. I’ll have to check to see if I’m under the African American category yet. Perhaps I’ll make the suggestion to be added if I’m not already.

@Thomas - Wow! You’ve really taken a lot of things into consideration regarding the passing along of all of your research. I’m sure whoever takes over will have no problem taking up where you leave off.

@Charles - I agree. With my blog post, I realize I probably wasn’t clear, but I was trying to explain that the information was regarding a passed relative, which a living relative felt affected by. In attempting to be vague, I realize that probably didn’t come across. Nonetheless, it’s still a matter of family privacy, for the living and the deceased.

Miriam, I also wanted to mention that I have checked out the other African American genealogy blogs and have made contact with Taneya of Taneya’s Genealogy and she has also been a great help to me.
George, thanks for your “two ducats.” And I’ll be sure to steer clear of putting any cousin Rons on blast. : )

It’s challenging! I blog/write with my heart & follow my conscious.

At the core, the reason why I do this is for Family preservation. I want the children & grands here and coming to know of the wonderful people they have been connected to through time.

That said, I am ’selective’ regarding stories that need to be told & stories that I am fine with knowing but don’t feel a need to publish.

Recently, I was asked by my Great Aunts to remove a commentary about my Great Uncle (deceased) & his Wife. Although the comments were not harmful in any way, they didn’t settle well with his living children.

At first I balked at the idea of editing the comment & then I thought about it, these children have suffered the loss of both parents before the age of 16. If the removal of a few lines could make a difference to them, it was fine by me.

As I said, I follow my conscious & keep in mind that my goal is to preserve history & not create new offenses.

Cheers,

Mechie

Hi Jeanna! Welcome to the world of Blogging!


 

Powered by WordPress and Tarski • Modifed by Charfish Design